1) Why?
2) Could there be a song with a more depressing title?
Sure, sure - the lyrics talk about recapturing the feeling - but wow. Can you imagine if someone came up to you and said "Didn't we almost have it all? You know you'll never love that way again."
I am not sure how I would feel about that. Part of me would want to tell them to stop putting words in my mouth - and I'm sure the other part would wonder if they were right.
Damn you hypothetical situation!